Former Arsenal legend and outspoken pundit Paul Merson has delivered a stinging verdict on Sheffield Wednesday’s chances of reaching the Premier League, claiming the club is nowhere near ready to compete at the top level. Speaking during a recent football segment, Merson didn’t hold back in his analysis of the Owls’ struggles, insisting their current squad and strategy leave them miles off the pace in the Championship, let alone the Premier League.
Merson highlighted Sheffield Wednesday’s lack of quality and depth as a glaring issue.
“Let’s be honest, Sheffield Wednesday will never play in the Premier League—not anytime soon. They don’t have that squad yet. There’s no spark, no consistency, and no players who can really take the game by the scruff of the neck,” Merson said.
He pointed to recent performances as evidence of their struggles to compete even in the Championship, let alone against the likes of Premier League giants.
“You’re not telling me this team could handle a game against Manchester City or Arsenal. They’re barely scraping by against mid-table Championship teams,” he added.
Merson also took aim at the club’s financial constraints and lack of a clear vision.
“Football is about planning these days. You can’t just hope for the best—you need a proper strategy, from recruitment to tactics. And, let’s face it, Wednesday don’t have that. They’re miles behind clubs like Leicester or Sunderland in terms of structure,” Merson explained.
While Merson acknowledged the passion of the fans, he argued that it isn’t enough to propel the club forward.
“The fans deserve better—they’re incredible. Hillsborough is a proper football ground with proper supporters. But the team on the pitch doesn’t match that passion. It’s heartbreaking, but that’s the reality,” he said.
For Sheffield Wednesday to have any chance of returning to the Premier League, Merson insists sweeping changes are required.
“They need investment—big investment—and a clear direction. Otherwise, they’re just treading water in the Championship. The Premier League? Forget about it for now,” he concluded.
Merson’s comments have sparked debate among Sheffield Wednesday supporters. While some see his words as harsh but fair, others feel he’s been unnecessarily critical of a club still finding its footing.
One thing is certain: Paul Merson’s blunt assessment has once again put Sheffield Wednesday in the spotlight, forcing tough questions about their future ambitions.